Objections to The Prosecution’s Closing Arguments In The Chauvin Trial: Speculations, Contradictions, And Lies

On Monday, both sides gave their closing arguments to the jurors in the Derek Chauvin trial in the death of George Floyd.

A full transcript of the prosecution’s closing arguments may be read here. A full transcript of the defense’s closing arguments may be read here. The Right Wire Report previous articles on the trial can be read here.

Here is a brief rundown of the prosecution’s closing argument as I see it.

MR. SCHLEICHER: (05:16)

Just a human, just a man, lying on the pavement being pressed upon, desperately crying out. A grown man, crying out for his mother.

Objection: speculation.

Legal insurrection.com:

“We’ve all seen the heart tugging video of Floyd restrained on the ground by officers after resisting lawful arrest, calling out repeatedly for “Mama.” I expect we’ve all presumed he was calling out for his mother.

On cross-examination by defense counsel Eric Nelson, however, there was a rather remarkable revelation:  Courteney Ross was listed in Floyd’s cell phone under the name “Mama.”

 

MR. SCHLEICHER: (07:51)

But George Floyd was not a threat to anyone. He wasn’t trying to hurt anyone. He wasn’t trying to do anything to anyone.

Objection: contradiction.

MR. SCHLEICHER: (19:47):  “Well, this all started over a call of an alleged counterfeit $20 bill.” 

Objection: lie.

George Floyd was in the store committing a crime by using a counterfeit $20 bill

 

MR. SCHLEICHER: (11:48)

Well, what you saw the defendant and the other officers doing to George Floyd caused his death.

Objection: speculation.

Cause of death: Undetermined.

 

MR. SCHLEICHER: (12:24)

What the defendant did to George Floyd killed him.

Objection: speculation.

Cause of death: undetermined.

 

MR. SCHLEICHER: (24:40):

“He was walking, he was talking, he was breathing as alive as any person, any human in this room.”

Objection: lie.

Autopsy report shows that George Floyd had abnormally high, and, quite possibly, lethal level of drugs in his system.

 

MR. SCHLEICHER: (26:03)

He does. That’s not resistance, that’s compliance. They order him. They want him handcuffed. He is handcuffed. That’s not resistance, that’s compliance.

 

Objection: contradiction.

MR. SCHLEICHER: (28:47)

“All of those things can cause someone to not resist, but just not be able to bring themselves to comply at that moment at that time, and this is nothing new.”

 

Objection: lie.

A video of George Floyd resisting arrest asking to go to the ground and fighting while request was being granted.

MR. SCHLEICHER: (33:16)

“They decided to shove him in the car. He just couldn’t be in the back of that car, and so they pull him out.”

Objection: lie.

The officers asked George Floyd to get in the car voluntarily.  When he refused and resisted, the officers let George Floyd lie on the ground per Floyd’s request.  In the above video, you can hear George Floyd continuously pleading: “I want to go on the ground.  I can’t breeze.”

 

MR. SCHLEICHER: (59:51)

He did not die of a drug overdose. That’s not how he died. He didn’t die of excited delirium.”

Objection: speculation.

Cause of death: undetermined.

 

My full response to the prosecution closing argument:

 RWR original article syndication source.

 

Share this:

What do you think?

Written by Tatyana Larina

Tatyana Larina comes from my favorite work of poetry.  And that's the only time you'll see me quoting Wikipedia as a source.

I came to the US in 1991, lived in San Francisco for 5 years, and I have a Computer Science degree.  I worked in software industry for several years, later switching to a career of a full time mom, and I never looked back.

In my younger days, I wasn’t a conservative. That is not to say that I was ever a liberal – I was not anything at all. I had no idea that there were such concepts as “conservative” and “liberal”. I did not pay attention to politics at all, and the most political knowledge you would get out of me would be who the US President was, and even for that you had to catch me on the right day.
My first introduction to politics was during the second Israeli intifada in 2002. Unspeakable violence erupted in Israel. Every day dozens of people were killed. Even though I didn’t follow politics, that deeply affected me. I felt sad, frustrated, and powerless. And one night, I happened to stumble on an MSNBC program called “Alan Keyes is making sense.” He was talking passionately about Israel and the violence, and he addressed my feelings very well.  Since that evening, I turned on Alan Keyes every night, and by his commentary he was able to take away some of the frustration and anger that I had. It was like a nightly therapy session.
Feeling intrigued after watching Alan Keyes, I wondered what else MSNBC had in store. I switched through the channels, and low and behold, I found Scarborough Country. Right off, Joe Scarborough wasn’t what he is today at all. He was a solid conservative (as I now understand), making common sense conservative points. I found him interesting and engaging. Opposing liberalism had not entered my mind at that time. I still didn’t know anything about liberalism. It was just the things he said sounded very common sense and worthwhile to me. Imagine that at some point, MSNBC had a conservative host on the air. Crazy times, ha?
Exploring my new political universe, I switched through more channels, and one night I found FOX. O’Reilly Factor was on. From the very first night, I was hooked. I abandoned Scarborough. O’Reilly was not just common sense – he was aggressive, and he was a fighter. He was Scarborough on steroids. He wasn’t just talking – he was taking on what he thought to be wrong and unjust. Ever since the first time, and until untimely end of Bill’s FOX career, I don’t think I ever missed one Factor.
For forming my political views, and my ability to formulate them, I have to give special credit to three people: Charles Krauthammer, Bill O’Reilly, and Greg Guttfeld.  To Charles - philosophy.  To Bill - realistic and pragmatic approach to politics.  To Greg - realization that a good joke will change more minds than a long lecture.
And for everything else, thanks to my family.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Chad’s President Idriss Déby dies after ‘clashes with rebels’

FNC’s Carlson: ‘Maxine Waters Is Someone Who Supports Mob Violence — She Always Has Supported, We Have Known This’